How I Found My Homeschooling Style (And How You Can Too!)

I recently had a really interesting conversation with an acquaintance who asked about my personal homeschool journey. She was thinking about homeschooling but felt overwhelmed by all the options—sound familiar? When I first started, I spent hours researching different methods, trying to figure out what would work best for my kids. Eventually, I found my stride as a mix of Waldorf and traditional homeschooling, but one thing I learned is that there’s no one-size-fits-all approach. Some kids thrive with one method, while others need a blend of different styles.

If you're trying to decide which homeschooling approach is right for your family, you're not alone! Here’s a breakdown of some of the most popular homeschooling methods, plus some pros and cons to help you figure out what might work best for your child.

1. Traditional Homeschooling (School at Home)

This approach looks a lot like a regular school classroom—structured lessons, textbooks, quizzes, and schedules. Some families use boxed curriculum programs that provide everything needed for a full school year.

✅ Best for: Families who like structure, those new to homeschooling, or kids who may transition back to traditional school.
🔹 Potential Challenges: Can feel rigid and may not work well for kids who prefer hands-on learning.

2. Charlotte Mason: Learning Through Living Books

Charlotte Mason homeschoolers rely on living books—engaging, well-written stories instead of dry textbooks. This method includes short lessons, nature studies, narration, and art appreciation.

✅ Best for: Families who love books, nature, and a gentle learning approach.
🔹 Potential Challenges: Requires parent involvement in selecting books and planning activities.

3. Classical Homeschooling: The Trivium Approach

Classical education follows a three-stage process:

• Grammar Stage (K-6): Memorization and foundational knowledge.

• Logic Stage (7-9): Critical thinking and reasoning.

• Rhetoric Stage (10-12): Persuasive writing and debate.

✅ Best for: Parents who love structure and deep learning.
🔹 Potential Challenges: Can feel demanding, and Latin is often included!

4. Montessori: Hands-On, Child-Led Learning

Maria Montessori’s method focuses on independence, real-world skills, and hands-on learning using carefully designed materials.

✅ Best for: Young kids, hands-on learners, and parents who like a prepared learning environment.
🔹 Potential Challenges: Requires specific materials and a well-organized space.

5. Waldorf: Creativity & Rhythmic Learning

Waldorf homeschooling emphasizes storytelling, art, music, and nature. Early childhood learning focuses on play, while academics are introduced gradually.

✅ Best for: Parents who value creativity, imagination, and a holistic approach.
🔹 Potential Challenges: Limited screen time and delayed academics may not work for every family.

6. Unschooling: Learning Through Life

Unschooling is the most flexible approach—it follows the child’s natural curiosity with no set curriculum. Learning happens through life experiences, projects, and exploration.

✅ Best for: Self-motivated learners and families who love flexibility.
🔹 Potential Challenges: Requires trust in the process; may be difficult in states with strict homeschool regulations.

7. Unit Studies: Learning by Theme

Unit studies focus on a single topic, integrating multiple subjects around it. For example, a space unit might include:
🚀 Reading books about astronauts (literature)
🚀 Measuring planets (math)
🚀 Building a rocket model (science)

✅ Best for: Hands-on learners and families with multiple ages learning together.
🔹 Potential Challenges: Requires planning or finding high-quality unit study resources.

8. Eclectic Homeschooling: A Mix of Everything

If you like bits and pieces of different methods, you’re an eclectic homeschooler! Many families combine styles to fit their child’s needs.

✅ Best for: Families who love flexibility and personalization.
🔹 Potential Challenges: Requires some trial and error.

How Do You Choose the Right Homeschool Approach?

During this conversation, I was asked how to best decide. The truth? You don’t have to pick just one! Many families mix and match until they find what works.

To decide what’s best for your family:
✅ Observe your child’s learning style—Do they prefer hands-on projects, structure, storytelling, or self-directed learning?
✅ Consider your teaching style—Are you comfortable with a flexible approach, or do you prefer structured lesson plans?
✅ Think about long-term goals—Do you want an academic-heavy approach, more creativity and exploration, or a mix of both?

At the end of the day, homeschooling is all about creating an environment where your child thrives. Whether you lean toward Charlotte Mason, Classical, Montessori, or Unschooling, the best thing you can do is embrace what works and adjust as needed.

Need Help Planning Your Homeschool Curriculum?

One of the biggest challenges of homeschooling is figuring out what to teach and when—especially if you’re just starting out. If you’re looking for a comprehensive, grade-by-grade guide, I highly recommend Home Learning Year by Year by Rebecca Rupp. This book breaks down essential subjects from preschool through high school, providing curriculum ideas, reading lists, and creative alternatives to help you design a homeschool plan that fits your child’s needs. Whether you prefer structured lessons, interest-led learning, or a mix of both, this resource can help you feel confident in your homeschooling journey!

Want More Homeschooling Tips?

At LearnWell, I help families navigate homeschooling by providing curriculum recommendations, resources, and tips to make learning at home simpler and more effective.

➡️ Check out my recommended homeschooling resources!
➡️ Follow LearnWell on Pinterest for curriculum ideas and homeschool organization tips!
➡️ Join my newsletter for homeschooling hacks, book lists, and exclusive content!

What homeschooling method works best for your family? Let me know in the comments!